Home[WINNERS ANNOUNCED] GFX Battle - DoYouPlay_RS vs. xDamon
+12
immmdave
Kelly
Julian
EnterRiftSpc
Towno
Maff
Lucky
Stealth
Jiri
Grim IReaper
PRISM
DoYouPlay_RS
16 posters
Index :: Social :: Graphics :: Graphics Archive
Page 1 of 1
Which one is best?
[WINNERS ANNOUNCED] GFX Battle - DoYouPlay_RS vs. xDamon
by DoYouPlay_RS 17/7/2012, 8:02 pm
Sorry, had to make a new topic because I couldnt make a new poll on the original one 
Ive been busy and couldnt put voting up, but here it is. All entries will remain anonymous until the end, first one to 10 votes wins. If no one gets 10 votes, the person with the highest votes after 4 days wins. When you vote, please say which one you voted for and why so the designers can improve in the future. So without further ado, here are the entries:
Entry #1:
![[WINNERS ANNOUNCED] GFX Battle - DoYouPlay_RS vs. xDamon Battledamonvdyp](https://2img.net/h/i1229.photobucket.com/albums/ee463/hydrumin/battledamonvdyp.png)
Entry #2:
![[WINNERS ANNOUNCED] GFX Battle - DoYouPlay_RS vs. xDamon Battledamonvsdyp](https://2img.net/h/i1229.photobucket.com/albums/ee463/hydrumin/battledamonvsdyp.png)
Ive been busy and couldnt put voting up, but here it is. All entries will remain anonymous until the end, first one to 10 votes wins. If no one gets 10 votes, the person with the highest votes after 4 days wins. When you vote, please say which one you voted for and why so the designers can improve in the future. So without further ado, here are the entries:Entry #1:
Entry #2:
- Rules:
Hey all, back with another idea I picked up called a GFX battle Basically, it is like a 2-person SOTW in essence, and its up to the public to decide the victor. To begin this, the host (the person who challenges another person) thinks up 10 themes and posts them in a second post. Then, they open up random.org and insert 1-10 and randomize, and the theme on the list that matches the number generated is the theme. Then, participants will have 48 hours to PM their entries to the host. After this, they will be edited into this post by the host and will go into the voting phase. NOTE: ALL VOTING WILL BE ANONYMOUS. What this means is names of the creators will not be revealed until the end of voting. The voting phase will go on for 4 days or until one person reaches 10 votes towards their signature. Then after one of those requirements are met, the creators will be revealed and the winner will get a free GFX at my shop (sorry, no better prize I can think of lmao) So without further ado, the first GFX battle...DoYouPlay_RS vs. xDamon!!
Rules:
- Your entry must be your own work and made by you; stealing other people's work will not be tolerated.
- Your graphic cannot be pre-made. The graphic must have been created during the allotted time.
- Within the signature you submit you must have it say what the theme is.
- No animated graphics, explicit images, text, or contents.
- Must follow all Smokin Mils rules.
- Your submission must not be any larger than 500x225.
Last edited by DoYouPlay_RS on 18/7/2012, 3:39 am; edited 1 time in total
DoYouPlay_RS- Grandmaster (2000 posts)
-
Re: [WINNERS ANNOUNCED] GFX Battle - DoYouPlay_RS vs. xDamon
by DoYouPlay_RS 17/7/2012, 10:02 pm
Guys, dont forget to say why you voted for the one you did
DoYouPlay_RS- Grandmaster (2000 posts)
-
Re: [WINNERS ANNOUNCED] GFX Battle - DoYouPlay_RS vs. xDamon
by PRISM 17/7/2012, 10:06 pm
I voted for number one, the whole monochromatic feel to it makes it look very armourish and reminds me that i have to play more runescape. The text also suits it well, but is hidding a bi too much.
PRISM- Forum Master (1500 posts)
Re: [WINNERS ANNOUNCED] GFX Battle - DoYouPlay_RS vs. xDamon
by Grim IReaper 17/7/2012, 10:08 pm
DoYouPlay_RS wrote:Guys, dont forget to say why you voted for the one you did
Sorry, I went with number two. I personally prefer the chaotic kind of signatures. And number one just seems very dull due to it being monochrome, and not much else going on around it.
Grim IReaper- Forum Addict (750 posts)
Re: [WINNERS ANNOUNCED] GFX Battle - DoYouPlay_RS vs. xDamon
by Jiri 17/7/2012, 10:21 pm
While number one is a very nice piece of GFX, I still went with number 2.
Number one just feels a bit too simple for a signature, it really feels like a photomanip and not that much of a signature.
Number 2's text could be improved though, I also dislike the border a little bit, doesn't seem to match the theme. Overall it's a better signature though, in my eyes.
Number one just feels a bit too simple for a signature, it really feels like a photomanip and not that much of a signature.
Number 2's text could be improved though, I also dislike the border a little bit, doesn't seem to match the theme. Overall it's a better signature though, in my eyes.
Jiri- Tier 3 (300 posts)
Re: [WINNERS ANNOUNCED] GFX Battle - DoYouPlay_RS vs. xDamon
by Stealth 17/7/2012, 10:49 pm
I voted number one. The text in the second image just ruins it for me. The border also is very amateur. I prefer a basic Bold black border. The smoothness in the first image is very nice to look at, and refines the text. The lighting in the first one is very good in the first one as well, as the second one seems to have two entry points, below the dragon, and behind it. Both decent pieces, but the first one trumps.
Stealth- Tier 2 (100 posts)
Re: [WINNERS ANNOUNCED] GFX Battle - DoYouPlay_RS vs. xDamon
by Lucky 18/7/2012, 2:40 am
If the voting was still open... I'd chose #1 simply because it fit the theme more... I'm not really sure what #2 is... >.<
Lucky- Grandmaster (2000 posts)
Re: [WINNERS ANNOUNCED] GFX Battle - DoYouPlay_RS vs. xDamon
by DoYouPlay_RS 18/7/2012, 2:41 am
Lucky wrote:If the voting was still open... I'd chose #1 simply because it fit the theme more... I'm not really sure what #2 is... >.<
Voting still is open
DoYouPlay_RS- Grandmaster (2000 posts)
-
Re: [WINNERS ANNOUNCED] GFX Battle - DoYouPlay_RS vs. xDamon
by Maff 18/7/2012, 2:45 am
Entry #2 because I absolutely love the coloring. Great work with the C4Ds as well 
Not sure how I feel about the borders though
Not sure how I feel about the borders though
Maff- Tier 2 (100 posts)
Re: [WINNERS ANNOUNCED] GFX Battle - DoYouPlay_RS vs. xDamon
by Lucky 18/7/2012, 3:04 am
DoYouPlay_RS wrote:Lucky wrote:If the voting was still open... I'd chose #1 simply because it fit the theme more... I'm not really sure what #2 is... >.<
Voting still is open
I didn't realise that since you linked the view results page over IRC
Lucky- Grandmaster (2000 posts)
Re: [WINNERS ANNOUNCED] GFX Battle - DoYouPlay_RS vs. xDamon
by Towno 18/7/2012, 3:21 am
I voted number 2, it appeals more to me.
Towno- Grandmaster (2000 posts)
Re: [WINNERS ANNOUNCED] GFX Battle - DoYouPlay_RS vs. xDamon
by DoYouPlay_RS 18/7/2012, 3:36 am
Voting closed. The winner is...
This was alot of fun, I highly encourage others to copy what we did
- Spoiler:
DoYouPlay_RS with 10 votes!!!
Runner-up was xDamon with 7 votes. Dont worry mate, you still did an awesome job with your entry
This was alot of fun, I highly encourage others to copy what we did
DoYouPlay_RS- Grandmaster (2000 posts)
-
Re: [WINNERS ANNOUNCED] GFX Battle - DoYouPlay_RS vs. xDamon
by Lucky 18/7/2012, 3:41 am
DYP could you perhaps explain what is in your Tag? I'm still not sure what exactly it is... ><
Lucky- Grandmaster (2000 posts)
Re: [WINNERS ANNOUNCED] GFX Battle - DoYouPlay_RS vs. xDamon
by EnterRiftSpc 18/7/2012, 3:42 am
Two wins, idk it just appealed to me. My vote won it , now who won?
EDIT: Sorry I'm blind... Grats DoYouPlay_RS and xdamon.
, now who won?EDIT: Sorry I'm blind... Grats DoYouPlay_RS and xdamon.
EnterRiftSpc- Forum Master (1500 posts)
Re: [WINNERS ANNOUNCED] GFX Battle - DoYouPlay_RS vs. xDamon
by Julian 18/7/2012, 3:48 am
I think one. The lines are cleaner and more simplistic which I like.
Julian- Grandmaster (2000 posts)
Re: [WINNERS ANNOUNCED] GFX Battle - DoYouPlay_RS vs. xDamon
by Kelly 18/7/2012, 4:44 am
Since people aren't aware of the winners being announced, I edited the poll so it will only run one more day. I can see if we can try to get this working to be a normal thing. I do like the idea of it. I think I'll send out a mass PM to the graphics section, see what people think of the idea.
Kelly- Grandmaster (2000 posts)
Re: [WINNERS ANNOUNCED] GFX Battle - DoYouPlay_RS vs. xDamon
by immmdave 18/7/2012, 5:04 am
i voted for entry number one because it looked way clean.
immmdave- Tier 3 (300 posts)
Re: [WINNERS ANNOUNCED] GFX Battle - DoYouPlay_RS vs. xDamon
by Stealth 18/7/2012, 5:12 am
I love these Signature battles. I used to do these in another gfx forum they're lots of fun.
they're lots of fun.
Stealth- Tier 2 (100 posts)
Re: [WINNERS ANNOUNCED] GFX Battle - DoYouPlay_RS vs. xDamon
by jigglehippo 18/7/2012, 9:23 am
Voted for the 1st one because the picture matches the theme =)
jigglehippo- Tier 3 (300 posts)
Re: [WINNERS ANNOUNCED] GFX Battle - DoYouPlay_RS vs. xDamon
by xDamon 18/7/2012, 2:44 pm
Congratz DYPRS
xDamon- Tier 3 (300 posts)
Re: [WINNERS ANNOUNCED] GFX Battle - DoYouPlay_RS vs. xDamon
by PRISM 18/7/2012, 2:47 pm
i hadn't noticed the black border arouns signature #1, not good! 
PRISM- Forum Master (1500 posts)
Re: [WINNERS ANNOUNCED] GFX Battle - DoYouPlay_RS vs. xDamon
by helloim96 5/1/2013, 8:03 pm
1 all the way!
helloim96- Tier 2 (100 posts)
Re: [WINNERS ANNOUNCED] GFX Battle - DoYouPlay_RS vs. xDamon
by todgott 5/1/2013, 8:36 pm
please do not gravedig, thanks
todgott- Tier 4 (500 posts)
Similar topics» GFX Battle - DoYouPlay_RS vs. xDamon
» [WINNERS ANNOUNCED] GFX Battle 4 - DoYouPlay_RS vs. Atlas
» [WINNERS ANNOUNCED] GFX Battle 6 - Ross L vs. Daxy
» [WINNERS ANNOUNCED] GFX Battle 8 - Jiggie vs. Kyoot
» [WINNERS ANNOUNCED] GFX Battle 9 - Ross L vs. Todgott vs. Tekiable (DQ'd)
» [WINNERS ANNOUNCED] GFX Battle 4 - DoYouPlay_RS vs. Atlas
» [WINNERS ANNOUNCED] GFX Battle 6 - Ross L vs. Daxy
» [WINNERS ANNOUNCED] GFX Battle 8 - Jiggie vs. Kyoot
» [WINNERS ANNOUNCED] GFX Battle 9 - Ross L vs. Todgott vs. Tekiable (DQ'd)
Index :: Social :: Graphics :: Graphics Archive
Page 1 of 1
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum