HomeSignature of the Week #77! Theme: Music! - WINNERS ANNOUNCED
+3
Stealth
Mr Rockeye
Inhaps
7 posters
Index :: Social :: Graphics :: Graphics Archive
Page 1 of 1
Which is the best entry?
Signature of the Week #77! Theme: Music! - WINNERS ANNOUNCED
by Inhaps 3/3/2014, 6:04 pm
Rules:
Your entry must be your own work; no stealing other people's work or entering in pre-made graphics
In the signature, please put SOTW or something related to the theme as the text
No animated entries, explicit images, text, or contents
Please include the render/stock used or a screen shot of the image in the program you used. You do not have to put up both.
Sizes are not super strict, please just try not to exceed 500x350 (or if vertical 350x500).
When in voting, you may not persuade others to vote for your entry, or vote for your own.
Prizes:
1st place: 10M
2nd place: 8M
3rd place: 4M
Public favourite: 3M
Judging System
We will have 3+ judges who will vote on all entries, and there will be a poll once the thread is in voting so you can decide your winner and favourite!
This is what the judges will be looking at so make sure you know! Each Section will be for a total of 10 points 40 total.
- Spoiler:
*Idea
--Concept
--Composition
*Technical
--Flow
--Depth
--Lighting
*Typography
--Quality
--Integration
*Execution
--Balance
--Overall quality
Be inspired:
author: [x]
Entry Deadline: March 10, 2014
FIRST PLACE and PUBLIC FAVOURITE: Stealth - 66.5/120
- Josh's critique - 20:
- Idea: 5/10
Technical: 5/10
Typography: 5/10
Execution: 5/10
An average sig. A lot to improve on though. Lighting is to harsh. You coulda added a new color so its not so two toned. Its over sharpened in parts. Blending needs work. Keep it up.
- Inhaps' critique - 29:
- Idea: 7/10
Technical: 8/10 - Too sharp in parts and the contrast is a bit too high overall.
Typography: 6/10 - Not very legible due to the harsh contrast.
Execution: 8/10
- Kelly's critique - 17.5:
- Idea: 5/10
Technical: 4.5/10
Typography: 3/10
Execution: 5/10 - The lighting on this is very hard on the eyes and for some reason a yellowy color while the rest of the lighting displayed throughout the piece isn't. You did a good job with depth and the composition of this works, but I would recommend using the dodge and burn tools some, as well working on trying to incorporate more final touches to your piece to give it that "wow!" effect.
SECOND PLACE: todgott - 59/120
- Josh's critique - 18:
- Idea: 4/10
Technical: 4/10
Typography: 4/10
Execution: 6/10
Seems Rushed. Type is hard to read. Colors don't work. Lighting is ok.. Your better then this.
- Inhaps' critique - 25:
- Idea: 7/10
Technical: 6/10
Typography: 6/10 - Minimalistic and the colours are nice but has some problems with legibility.
Execution: 6/10 - Overall the colours are weird, especially the blob on the right.
- Kelly's critique - 16:
- Idea: 5/10
Technical: 3/10
Typography: 4/10
Execution: 4/10 - Not your best work in my opinion. The colors seem really weird and the typography works, but is hard to read. Your lighting is alright, though.
THIRD PLACE: Leakee - 50/120
- Josh's critique - 14:
- Idea: 3/10
Technical: 3/10
Typography: 4/10
Execution: 4/10
It looks as if you just tried blending a background of candy into the back of a render. Type is ok. Keep learning contact me personally if you want help. Keep learning.
- Inhaps' critique - 19:
- Idea: 6/10
Technical: 5/10 - Over-sharpened in parts which makes for a dirty lo-fi look. The lines and swirls might be better if toned down.
Typography: 3/10 - Pink and green is flat out ugly and neither of the fonts really match the tone of the sig.
Execution: 5/10
- Kelly's critique - 17:
- Idea: 5/10
Technical: 4/10
Typography: 4/10
Execution: 4/10 - Not entirely blended well in my opinion, but the concept is unique to say the least.
Mr Rockeye - 49/120
- Josh's critique - 13:
- Idea: 3/10
Technical: 3/10
Typography: 3/10
Execution: 4/10
Effects are a cool but horrible blended. You have to many colors it just doesn't work. I like the idea I did a kanye sig a while back that kinda had the same idea.- Spoiler:
- http://fc00.deviantart.net/fs70/f/2013/026/8/d/kanye_by_joshuadesigns-d5suvch.jpg
- Inhaps' critique - 20:
- Idea: 6/10
Technical: 5/10
Typography: 4/10 - Has a cheap tang to it.
Execution: 5/10 - The whole composition needs something to unify it because most everything just feels like it is in its own little world.
- Kelly's critique - 16:
- Idea: 5/10
Technical: 3/10
Typography: 4/10
Execution: 4/10 - Sort of looks like an acid trip gone wrong. The concept of this is great, but honestly this particular render isn't really suited for the vector style.
Last edited by Inhaps on 24/3/2014, 6:16 pm; edited 3 times in total
Inhaps- Grandmaster (2000 posts)
Re: Signature of the Week #77! Theme: Music! - WINNERS ANNOUNCED
by Mr Rockeye 3/3/2014, 10:00 pm
Yay this means I'm finally able to use renders I've never used before! :p
Mr Rockeye- Tier 4 (500 posts)
Re: Signature of the Week #77! Theme: Music! - WINNERS ANNOUNCED
by Stealth 4/3/2014, 5:33 am
My Entry:
- Proof:
Stealth- Tier 2 (100 posts)
Re: Signature of the Week #77! Theme: Music! - WINNERS ANNOUNCED
by Music 4/3/2014, 6:27 am
So does this mean I get to use these signatures? :3
Music- Grandmaster (2000 posts)
Re: Signature of the Week #77! Theme: Music! - WINNERS ANNOUNCED
by Inhaps 4/3/2014, 7:06 am
Music wrote:So does this mean I get to use these signatures? :3
If you have no shame.
Inhaps- Grandmaster (2000 posts)
Re: Signature of the Week #77! Theme: Music! - WINNERS ANNOUNCED
by Mr Rockeye 4/3/2014, 8:50 pm
My entry:
- Render:
Mr Rockeye- Tier 4 (500 posts)
Re: Signature of the Week #77! Theme: Music! - WINNERS ANNOUNCED
by Kelly 5/3/2014, 7:18 am
Good luck everyone! Some good entries so far ^^.
I hopefully will be taking part in this weeks SOTW.
Really excited to, even have a render in mind to use.
I hopefully will be taking part in this weeks SOTW.
Really excited to, even have a render in mind to use.
Kelly- Grandmaster (2000 posts)
Re: Signature of the Week #77! Theme: Music! - WINNERS ANNOUNCED
by Leakee 6/3/2014, 10:09 pm
- Spoiler:
Leakee- Grandmaster (2000 posts)
-
Re: Signature of the Week #77! Theme: Music! - WINNERS ANNOUNCED
by todgott 10/3/2014, 7:43 pm
sry for quality, had no internet or resources.
Will add proof tomorrow
todgott- Tier 4 (500 posts)
Re: Signature of the Week #77! Theme: Music! - WINNERS ANNOUNCED
by Leakee 16/3/2014, 6:39 pm
Good luck voting ladies and gentlemanoes
Leakee- Grandmaster (2000 posts)
-
Re: Signature of the Week #77! Theme: Music! - WINNERS ANNOUNCED
by Inhaps 24/3/2014, 6:18 pm
Congratulations, Stealth, todgott and Leakee!
Join #Design to arrange a time and place for your prize.
Join #Design to arrange a time and place for your prize.
Inhaps- Grandmaster (2000 posts)
Sponsored content
Similar topics» Signature of the Week #81! Theme: War! - WINNERS ANNOUNCED
» Signature of the Week #78! Theme: Television! - WINNERS ANNOUNCED
» Signature of the Week #79! Theme: Space! - WINNERS ANNOUNCED
» Signature of the Week #90! Theme: Holidays! - WINNERS ANNOUNCED
» Signature of the Week #91! Theme: Seaside - WINNERS ANNOUNCED
» Signature of the Week #78! Theme: Television! - WINNERS ANNOUNCED
» Signature of the Week #79! Theme: Space! - WINNERS ANNOUNCED
» Signature of the Week #90! Theme: Holidays! - WINNERS ANNOUNCED
» Signature of the Week #91! Theme: Seaside - WINNERS ANNOUNCED
Index :: Social :: Graphics :: Graphics Archive
Page 1 of 1
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum|
|
|