~*~ SOTW #65 ~*~ WINNERS ANNOUNCED
+8
PredatorGFX
Magic
Atlas
cntr
DoYouPlay_RS
Inomonu
Leakee
Kelly
12 posters
Index :: Social :: Graphics :: Graphics Archive
Page 1 of 1
~*~ SOTW #65 ~*~ WINNERS ANNOUNCED
Rules:
- Your entry must be your own work and made by you; stealing other people's work will not be tolerated.
- Your graphic cannot be pre-made. The graphic must have been created during the allotted time.
- Within the signature you submit you must have it say SOTW or what the theme is.
- No animated graphics, explicit images, text, or contents.
- Must follow all Smokin Mils rules (found here).
- Your submission must not be any larger than 500x225 (if vertical then 225x500)
-When voting is up, you may not persuade others to vote for your entry. The object is to have people choose what they like the most and\or feel is the best
-Include in your post the render or stock that you used to create the graphic. Alternative to this, you can post up a screenshot of the programs that you used to help create the graphic with the layers tab showing. You DO NOT have to put up both.
Prizes:
- 1st place: 5M
- 2nd place: 3M
- 3rd place: 1M
- Public favorite: 1M
Theme: Dragons
Entry Deadline: Friday, January 11th
- Your entry must be your own work and made by you; stealing other people's work will not be tolerated.
- Your graphic cannot be pre-made. The graphic must have been created during the allotted time.
- Within the signature you submit you must have it say SOTW or what the theme is.
- No animated graphics, explicit images, text, or contents.
- Must follow all Smokin Mils rules (found here).
- Your submission must not be any larger than 500x225 (if vertical then 225x500)
-When voting is up, you may not persuade others to vote for your entry. The object is to have people choose what they like the most and\or feel is the best
-Include in your post the render or stock that you used to create the graphic. Alternative to this, you can post up a screenshot of the programs that you used to help create the graphic with the layers tab showing. You DO NOT have to put up both.
Prizes:
- 1st place: 5M
- 2nd place: 3M
- 3rd place: 1M
- Public favorite: 1M
Theme: Dragons
Entry Deadline: Friday, January 11th
~ * ~ * ~ * ~ * ~
VOTING:
Please choose your favorite three entries like so:
1. [insert entrants name here]
2. [insert entrants name here]
3. [insert entrants name here]
Entries:
First place & public favorite: Kelly
Proof: [X]
Third place: Leakee
Proof: [X]
Third place: DoYouPlay_RS
Proof: Please post proof asap
Inomou
Proof: [X]
VOTING:
Please choose your favorite three entries like so:
1. [insert entrants name here]
2. [insert entrants name here]
3. [insert entrants name here]
Entries:
First place & public favorite: Kelly
Proof: [X]
- DoYouPlay_RS's critique:
Theme (rate from 1-10): 10
Lighting, flow, depth (rate from 1-10): 9, really nice
Typography (rate from 1-10): 8
Creativity (rate from 1-10): 8
Overall feel\look\effectiveness\composition (rate from 1-10): 9
Other:
- Kelly's critique:
Theme (rate from 1-10): 8.5, hard to see the dragon
Lighting, flow, depth (rate from 1-10): 8
Typography (rate from 1-10): 7, good text usage, but a bit far away from the render
Creativity (rate from 1-10): 8, would be higher if only the dragon were to stand out a bit more; too blended into the background
Overall feel\look\effectiveness\composition (rate from 1-10): 8
Other:
- Public Vote Tallies:
First place votes: 3
Second place votes: 1
Third place votes: 1
Total tally of votes: 120
Total points (including P.F): 203.5
Third place: Leakee
Proof: [X]
- DoYouPlay_RS's critique:
Theme (rate from 1-10): 9
Lighting, flow, depth (rate from 1-10): 4, very poor
Typography (rate from 1-10): 5.5, can be alot better
Creativity (rate from 1-10): 6
Overall feel\look\effectiveness\composition (rate from 1-10): 7
Other:
- Kelly's critique:
Theme (rate from 1-10): 10
Lighting, flow, depth (rate from 1-10): 7, there really isn't any distinct lighting or depth.
Typography (rate from 1-10): 7.5, seems a bit too dark and almost far-ish away from the render, but the layout works
Creativity (rate from 1-10): 7.5
Overall feel\look\effectiveness\composition (rate from 1-10): 8
Other:
- Public Vote Tallies:
First place votes: 1
Second place votes: 4
Third place votes: 1
Total tally of votes: 120
Total points (including P.F): 191.5
Third place: DoYouPlay_RS
Proof: Please post proof asap
- DoYouPlay_RS's critique:
Theme (rate from 1-10): 10
Lighting, flow, depth (rate from 1-10): 8, lighting is too intense
Typography (rate from 1-10): 8, can be cleaned up
Creativity (rate from 1-10): 8
Overall feel\look\effectiveness\composition (rate from 1-10): 8.5
Other:
- Kelly's critique:
Theme (rate from 1-10): 10
Lighting, flow, depth (rate from 1-10): 7.5, seems a tiny bit too harshly lit, but not much
Typography (rate from 1-10):5.5, seems plain and a bit too far away from the render, but works, also took off 1 point because you put the wrong number of the sotw xD
Creativity (rate from 1-10): 8
Overall feel\look\effectiveness\composition (rate from 1-10): 8
Other:
- Public Vote Tallies:
First place votes: 2
Second place votes: 1
Third place votes: 2
Total tally of votes: 100
Total points (including P.F): 181.5
Inomou
Proof: [X]
- DoYouPlay_RS's critique:
Theme (rate from 1-10): 7, I cant see the dragon well at all
Lighting, flow, depth (rate from 1-10): 6, needs alot of cleaning up
Typography (rate from 1-10): 6, stands out way too much
Creativity (rate from 1-10): 7, I like your style
Overall feel\look\effectiveness\composition (rate from 1-10): 6.5
Other: Again, I like your style, it just needs alot of cleaning up is all
- Kelly's critique:
Theme (rate from 1-10): 8.5, hard to see the dragon
Lighting, flow, depth (rate from 1-10): 6
Typography (rate from 1-10): 5
Creativity (rate from 1-10): 6.5
Overall feel\look\effectiveness\composition (rate from 1-10): 7
Other:
- Public Vote Tallies:
First place votes: 0
Second place votes: 0
Third place votes: 1
Total Points for P.F Votes: 10
Total points (including P.F): 75.5
Last edited by Kelly on 18/1/2013, 11:38 pm; edited 5 times in total
Kelly- Grandmaster (2000 posts)
Re: ~*~ SOTW #65 ~*~ WINNERS ANNOUNCED
First Entry! Worked pretty hard on this so I can only hope I do well!
And...
Proof:
Render looks kinda crappy but it is what it is
And...
Proof:
- Spoiler:
Render looks kinda crappy but it is what it is
Last edited by Leakee on 6/1/2013, 4:15 pm; edited 1 time in total
Re: ~*~ SOTW #65 ~*~ WINNERS ANNOUNCED
Well, I gave it a go. I enjoyed this theme, thanks Kelly
Upon looking at it, I see quite a few flaws, but I'll rectify it next time.
- Spoiler:
Upon looking at it, I see quite a few flaws, but I'll rectify it next time.
Inomonu- Forum Fanatic (1000 posts)
Re: ~*~ SOTW #65 ~*~ WINNERS ANNOUNCED
Tried something new
[Proof Link]
This ends later on today, so get any last minute entries in!
[Proof Link]
This ends later on today, so get any last minute entries in!
Kelly- Grandmaster (2000 posts)
Re: ~*~ SOTW #65 ~*~ WINNERS ANNOUNCED
Making entry now
EDIT: This render is always in every single Dragon SOTW out there I have a weeks worth of rust, so it isnt that good
EDIT: This render is always in every single Dragon SOTW out there I have a weeks worth of rust, so it isnt that good
Re: ~*~ SOTW #65 ~*~ WINNERS ANNOUNCED
This is now in voting, good luck everyone!
My votes
1 DoYouPlay_RS
2 Leakee
3 Inomonu
My votes
1 DoYouPlay_RS
2 Leakee
3 Inomonu
Kelly- Grandmaster (2000 posts)
Re: ~*~ SOTW #65 ~*~ WINNERS ANNOUNCED
Why does dyprs' say sotw 55 and not 65??
Atlas- Tier 4 (500 posts)
Re: ~*~ SOTW #65 ~*~ WINNERS ANNOUNCED
Atlas wrote:Why does dyprs' say sotw 55 and not 65??
Looks like a typo
Kelly- Grandmaster (2000 posts)
Re: ~*~ SOTW #65 ~*~ WINNERS ANNOUNCED
1. DYPRS
2. Leakee
3. Kelly
Oh and Hi everyone! Does anyone remember me? (New Account, forgot pass to old one..)
2. Leakee
3. Kelly
Oh and Hi everyone! Does anyone remember me? (New Account, forgot pass to old one..)
Magic- Tier 1 (Registered)
Re: ~*~ SOTW #65 ~*~ WINNERS ANNOUNCED
Carbon wrote:1. DYPRS
2. Leakee
3. Kelly
Oh and Hi everyone! Does anyone remember me? (New Account, forgot pass to old one..)
My 2nd favorite designer in SM is back
Re: ~*~ SOTW #65 ~*~ WINNERS ANNOUNCED
1. Kelly
2. Leakee
3. Not going to vote for third
2. Leakee
3. Not going to vote for third
Broeder- Grandmaster (2000 posts)
Re: ~*~ SOTW #65 ~*~ WINNERS ANNOUNCED
Kelly, don't you think judging your own work could be a bit ... whats the word i'm looking for... biased?
todgott- Tier 4 (500 posts)
Re: ~*~ SOTW #65 ~*~ WINNERS ANNOUNCED
todgott wrote:Kelly, don't you think judging your own work could be a bit ... whats the word i'm looking for... biased?
http://www.smokinelite.com/t70024p45-please-read-compeition-ideas#1000263
Read the last few posts.
Kelly- Grandmaster (2000 posts)
Re: ~*~ SOTW #65 ~*~ WINNERS ANNOUNCED
It depends how you handle it as a judge.. if your voting yourself as the best most times theres something wrong. Personally if i where to enter and judge i would be giving myself 7's. Because i think that i can always do better. But if your giving yourself 8s and 9s and 10s. Idk. Depends on the piece as well.
Josh Designs- Forum Addict (750 posts)
Re: ~*~ SOTW #65 ~*~ WINNERS ANNOUNCED
Even if I were to re-judged and gave myself all 7's, I would still have gotten first place, as it's only a 4.5 point difference total...
Kelly- Grandmaster (2000 posts)
Re: ~*~ SOTW #65 ~*~ WINNERS ANNOUNCED
Give it some time, i myself think kelly gave some higher grades to her sig as i would have given. But that happens on every sig she judges and so in the end it doesnt matter.
But give it some time, like 3 more sotw's at least
But give it some time, like 3 more sotw's at least
Broeder- Grandmaster (2000 posts)
Re: ~*~ SOTW #65 ~*~ WINNERS ANNOUNCED
;if anything, i judge myself LOWER than another judge because i notice all the flaws easier.
Re: ~*~ SOTW #65 ~*~ WINNERS ANNOUNCED
8 points plus on each grade is not low at all.. Im willing to see how this works though. It depends on the judges on how its handled.DoYouPlay_RS wrote:;if anything, i judge myself LOWER than another judge because i notice all the flaws easier.
Josh Designs- Forum Addict (750 posts)
Similar topics
» SOTW #20 - WINNERS ANNOUNCED
» ~*~ SOTW #33 ~*~ WINNERS ANNOUNCED
» ~*~ SOTW #46 ~*~ WINNERS ANNOUNCED
» ~*~ SOTW #21 ~*~ WINNERS ANNOUNCED!
» ~*~ SOTW #34 ~*~ WINNERS ANNOUNCED
» ~*~ SOTW #33 ~*~ WINNERS ANNOUNCED
» ~*~ SOTW #46 ~*~ WINNERS ANNOUNCED
» ~*~ SOTW #21 ~*~ WINNERS ANNOUNCED!
» ~*~ SOTW #34 ~*~ WINNERS ANNOUNCED
Index :: Social :: Graphics :: Graphics Archive
Page 1 of 1
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
|
|