Signature of the Week #74! Theme: Heroes vs Villains - WINNERS ANNOUNCED

FIRST PLACE and PUBLIC FAVOURITE: Mr Rockeye - 98/160

[x]

Josh's critique - 22:

Leakee's critique - 28:

Kelly's critique - 23:

Minato's critique - 25:

SECOND PLACE: Valets - 45/160

Josh's critique - 6:

Leakee's critique - 9.5:

Kelly's critique - 9.5:

Minato's critique - 20:

THIRD PLACE: feedpenguins - 38/160

Josh's critique - 10:

Leakee's critique - 8:

Kelly's critique - 9:

Minato's critique - 11:

Goodluck all :s i hope im doing this right

Spoiler:

Valets wrote:Goodluck all :s i hope im doing this right

Spoiler:

Good! Althought its Super Big, maybe try scaling it down a bit?

Did the size change, i've been playing around with the size now and can't seem to get it right >.>

Valets wrote:Goodluck all :s i hope im doing this right

Spoiler:

It's just a bit too large. Yours is 456x640 but it should be 350x500 at most. I've resized it for you.

resized image:

I also suggest using Imgur or Photobucket to upload your images with no quality loss.

Thank you Inhaps, ill be sure to try these sites out for future reference lmao.

3 more days to get entries in!!!!!

My entry:

Signature:

second attempt:

Proof of the render:

Choose the villain because why not?

Mr Rockeye wrote:My entry:

Signature:

Proof of the render:

Choose the villain because why not?

Epic Villain   

Leakee wrote:

Mr Rockeye wrote:My entry:

Signature:

Proof of the render:

Choose the villain because why not?

Epic Villain   

Thanks xD tried my best and butters for the win!

Okay, i'm not feeling to well about winning now lmao.. good one though, think it maybe a winner!

im a noob to photoshop so hopefully i did a decent job

Signature

Spoiler:

Screenshot of image used

Spoiler:

Thank you for your entries!

All of them could be greatly improved, but i went with Mr Rockeye. Will be in the next one; didnt like this theme too much

Sort of forgot about this... Next time!

i thought Valets one was not too bad. I liked the concept but it was not technical enough. Like the fact that you split the sig in two and put vilains and heroes like it was a versus was good but the typography and the triangles did not make it for me, also it looked like you just pasted two pictures and wrote over it. You were almost there but sadly did not put the effort or did not have the expertise to push the idea.

I thought Mr Rockeyes one was okay, like if I had to grade it, I would say that the background is sick, the focal point is good, the effects are great but I would have loved if you put a vilain and a heroe in it like Valets did just to show a fight a conflict in the picture or something.

About feedpenguins sig, I would say that I have no idea what you tried to do, it looked to me that you were high as fuck and that you put things all together to participate in the competition. I am not saying its shit, because I am 10x worse then this but I am saying that you have to show a clear idea of what you want to show in your next try and improve your effects. Good luck

I should be studying and I am writting an essay about sigs, fucking jesus christ fucking shit

wow i feel like i just got kicked in the chest. this was my first attempt at a sig like i said im noob to photoshop but thanks for your advice and ill keep it in mind for next time

feedpenguins wrote:wow i feel like i just got kicked in the chest. this was my first attempt at a sig like i said im noob to photoshop but thanks for your advice and ill keep it in mind for next time

Don't worry, there are always things to improve.
My signature is also not perfect, all you need to do is watch some YouTube guides.
Those guides helped me out a ton.
Remember you will always have failing pieces but it's what makes your art better.

Mr Rockeye wrote:

feedpenguins wrote:wow i feel like i just got kicked in the chest. this was my first attempt at a sig like i said im noob to photoshop but thanks for your advice and ill keep it in mind for next time

Don't worry, there are always things to improve.
My signature is also not perfect, all you need to do is watch some YouTube guides.
Those guides helped me out a ton.
Remember you will always have failing pieces but it's what makes your art better.

thank you
ive been reading tutorials. i find that the ones that are typed with pictures are better cause then you dont have to pause the videos or go back in the video if you have missed something

feedpenguins wrote:

Mr Rockeye wrote:

feedpenguins wrote:wow i feel like i just got kicked in the chest. this was my first attempt at a sig like i said im noob to photoshop but thanks for your advice and ill keep it in mind for next time

Don't worry, there are always things to improve.
My signature is also not perfect, all you need to do is watch some YouTube guides.
Those guides helped me out a ton.
Remember you will always have failing pieces but it's what makes your art better.

thank you
ive been reading tutorials. i find that the ones that are typed with pictures are better cause then you dont have to pause the videos or go back in the video if you have missed something

Try deviantart, that is where I learned how to do them. Search 'forum signature tutorial'.

Leakee wrote:

feedpenguins wrote:

Mr Rockeye wrote:

feedpenguins wrote:wow i feel like i just got kicked in the chest. this was my first attempt at a sig like i said im noob to photoshop but thanks for your advice and ill keep it in mind for next time

Don't worry, there are always things to improve.
My signature is also not perfect, all you need to do is watch some YouTube guides.
Those guides helped me out a ton.
Remember you will always have failing pieces but it's what makes your art better.

thank you
ive been reading tutorials. i find that the ones that are typed with pictures are better cause then you dont have to pause the videos or go back in the video if you have missed something

Try deviantart, that is where I learned how to do them. Search 'forum signature tutorial'.

lots of good helpful tutorials. thank you so much. these will keep me busy for a while

Well Nemo since you said you liked mine I feel like I won something in the inside <3 lmao joking I hate you